Five Minis have been given performance and aesthetic JCW enhancements, but which of these petrol and electric funsters is best?
Mini has long been the benchmark for expertly exploiting its heritage. Slinging the John Cooper Works badge on its line-up has proved lucrative indeed; the ‘JCW’ name synonymous with motorsport success.
Buyers seeking a hot hatch, hill climb special or just a sporty-looking everyday driver coated in black and red are drawn to anything JCW-branded. And there’s now a solid selection, as John Cooper Works editions land on five 2025 Mini models.
At an unconventional launch day, we were granted brief closed-road test drives of the full JCW range.
Our steeds were JCW editions of Mini’s three-door petrol hatch and convertible; the petrol Countryman small/medium all-wheel-drive SUV; electric-only Aceman city SUV, and titchy EV version of the three-door hatch.
You’re probably thinking the same as me. Should the JCW badge really adorn soft tops, top-heavy SUVs and electric cars? It’s 2025, the world’s changed, so of course they should. Just look to BMW “M” for how to profit from blanket coverage.
And these JCW Minis don’t just score body enhancements. There’s proper performance hikes and chassis fettling, justifying the tuner’s badge.
To briefly remind, Mini Coopers won three Monte Carlo Rallies in the 1960s, took the top nine places (really) at Bathurst in 1966, and as John Cooper Works, have won WRC rallies and taken class wins at the Dakar Rally and Nürburgring 24 Hours.
BMW bought rights to the tuning company’s name in 2007, and drops the badge on Mini’s most extreme, performance-oriented models.
What’s amusing is how the term “go-kart” is still bandied around like confetti at Mini launches. Back in 2001, on one of my first jobs as a motoring writer, “go-kart-like handling” was emphasised for this first new-shape Mini produced under BMW’s guardianship.
Some quarter-of-a-century later, the tag remains. “Mini is about the go-kart feeling, and when you look at John Cooper Works, this is about pinnacle go-kart feeling,” said Mini Australia GM Alex Brockhoff.
Can a 1745kg Aceman SUV with an electric motor really do a go-kart impression, or is that pushing the claim too far?
We saddled up to test the range, discover if each is worthy of a JCW badge, and which is worthiest of all.
For reference, interiors are very similar (and funky) across all JCW models.
This includes vegan (fake) leather and cloth seats which are well-bolstered; chairs are heated and with lots of red stitching, there’s a 240mm central OLED screen, glass roof (except for the convertible, obviously), wireless phone charging and mirroring, Harman/Kardon audio, surround-view cameras, and have all the key active safety kit.
Kudos to the canvas-like patterned dash and door tops, neat canvas strap at the base of the chunky steering wheel, and quick-access “Boost” button by your left thumb, which moves you into Go-Kart mode.
This setting brings a too-cringe cheer and round of applause, but in better news, sharpens throttle response and steering, frees up all the power, and for the combustion versions, puts the adaptive suspension to its lowest setting (the EVs miss out on the latter).
We start with the little EV. It, like the Aceman EV, are assembled in China, whereas combustion models still hail from Oxford, England.
Shorter than a Mazda 2, this ickle EV is the fastest front-wheel-drive Mini on sale, offering 190kW/350Nm and taking 5.9 seconds to reach 100km/h. Its range is 371km with 49.8kW (net) battery and 95kW DC charging capability. Expect 30 minutes to go from 10-80 per cent.
It’s a delightful cabin, albeit with two tiny rear seats and shoebox (210L) boot. You sit low in a lovely driving position, and before even setting off it feels eager to go corner hunting.
Wow. There’s instant torque hit in this tiny hatchback, and it feels properly fast. Its performance 18-inch tyres (brand depends on availability) prevent any wheelspin, and torque steer’s barely a thing unless you’ve got a bit of lock on.
There’s a whooshy fake sound as accompaniment, and it darts into corners with the enthusiasm of a spring lamb. But it’s not the final word in nimbleness; this little EV weighs 1650kg after all, which is around 350kg over the combustion version.
It means I come away more impressed with the e-motor’s performance, and this JCW E three-door’s grip and balance, rather than it being a riot of driver involvement. It’s still bloody good fun, though.
Same e-motor, battery, kW and Nm peaks as the three-door hatch, but the Aceman EV’s size and weight (1745kg) drops the 0-100km/h time to 6.4 seconds. Electric range is down to 355km.
Its five doors, five seats, SUV shape and larger (300L) boot for only a couple of grand more will make it a better seller than the hatch, and in the metal, it also wins for visual flair with its chunky wheel arches and edgier rather than round headlights.
There’s still grin-bringing torque-pull as soon as you throttle-on, and I’m surprised how close it is to the smaller car in terms of fun and cornering ability.
Having that weight and centre of gravity low down means it sits impressively flat in corners, but the 19-inch rubber is working pretty hard when you push it.
I get a lot more tyre squeal and must dial off some steering to shush it, and it feels a bit lardy in the tight turns. Aceman JCWs won’t be regular track toys you’d imagine, but credit where it’s due, this weighty city SUV still brought me smiles. But purer JCW experiences lay elsewhere.
The one furthest away from the true Mini ethos. This whopper of a small/medium SUV isn’t mini at all; it’s not far off Toyota RAV4-sized. But of course it’s needed in the line-up, as Mini shoppers that require proper family space will opt for one over the rest in this line-up, which are really best suited to two occupants.
It’s the most powerful and quickest JCW in out test. Its 2.0L turbo four-cylinder petrol offers a solid 233kW/400Nm, and thanks to all-wheel-drive, gets those numbers onto the road effectively, helping it hit 100km/h in 5.4 seconds.
It’s also thirstiest here, drinking 7.7L/100km of the required super unleaded. Fuel bills will add to that challenging purchase price. At around $80,000 on the road, you’re flirting with larger Audi Q5 and Lexus NX money.
Helping our track test, the Countryman’s a significant 200kg lighter than the Aceman EV I’ve just hopped out of, despite much more rear space and a proper (505L) boot.
It’s nice to finally be burning fossil fuels. In Go Kart mode the exhaust has a rortier note (through the speakers, mainly), and it’s nice to blip a throttle and get real vibrations.
The acceleration takes me by surprise. It’s mega. The instant torque can’t compete with the EVs, but there’s more muscle here, and the seven-speed dual-clutch jinks between cogs smoothly and rapidly. Much more involving too, even if it’s just from using paddle shifters.
The first corners show a bit of body roll, but nothing to put you off. The adaptive suspension does a solid job, but it doesn’t seem to turn in as neatly as the electric hatchback did. The SUV curse, I decide.
I feel it’s the car here that’d be most likely to get me into trouble. A wet corner has its back end step out as it didn’t enjoy my over-eager direction change. It’s not feeling very go-karty, but it is fast, fun enough and deeply impressive for a family SUV.
I’m a bit excited about this one. Back in my misspent youth, I’d borrow a mate’s fun-packed 1978 Mini 1275 GT in exchange for my VW Beetle, and since then I’ve had a soft spot for the smallest, cheapest sport-focused Mini on offer.
These days, that’s this JCW 3dr. It weighs twice that of my old mate’s 1275 GT (which had the structural integrity of a Coke can), but at 1300kg, is a lightweight by 2025’s standards.
It’s also the cheapest here (but not cheap) and closest to what a true “go-kart” Mini should be. Its four-cylinder petrol turbo gives 170kW and 380Nm, and helps it hit 100km/h in 6.1 seconds. That’s ample for a hot hatch.
I’ll get this out of the way now. This car should have a manual gearbox option. But like all Minis produced today, that’s just not offered.
I know there’s low uptake (Mini claims 3 per cent opted for three pedals when it was available), but if Hyundai can do it with its i20N and i30N, those are the cars proper enthusiasts will migrate to.
But dammit this thing is still so much fun with paddle shifters. There’s mega torque from the 2.0L turbo, and it sounds excellent at the redline, if still a little muted. After a few corners I’m in no doubt. This is the one to chuck around and feel utterly confident.
It feels tiny, darty and nimble. In no time I’m in lift-off oversteer heaven, with little lifts tucking the nose in, then big lifts rotating the rear beautifully; the electronic aids allowing a good dose of sideways before chucking the safety net.
I reckon I’m cornering quickest of anything I’ve driven so far, and start noticing how firm it is over bumps. Maybe it’ll be a bit stiff as a road car (we didn’t get the chance to test), as JCWs in the past have been somewhat spine-challenging.
But for now, this rapid corner hero is my new crush. It’s great fun, but also shows a mature poise, rather than anything too raw. If you’re into that (rather than something like a Hyundai i20N), you’ll adore this JCW three-door.
It’s seven grand more to go topless, but you can see the appeal. It mirrors the tin-top Mini’s engine and specification, but you’ve got the rag top for sun-on-face playtime.
These weigh 1400kg and drop the 0-100km/h to 6.4 seconds, which still feels quick enough when you’re exposed to the elements. It doesn’t feel as tight as the hardtop in the turns, but it’s really not far off.
It’s the poseurs’ special, and lovely to see with a JCW badge, but you can hop in a Mini Cooper Classic Convertible with a punchy enough three-cylinder turbo from $51,990 – that’s the open car to pick.
All these JCWs have their place, but there is, as expected, one that wears the badge with the most credibility.
The award for the truest go-kart experience goes to the JCW three-door petrol hatchback, and it is the pick if you’ll not be using the rear seats on a regular basis. As a happy bonus, it’s also the cheapest one you can buy.
Key specs (as tested)
About Chasing cars
Chasing Cars reviews are 100% independent.
Because we are powered by Budget Direct Insurance, we don’t receive advertising or sales revenue from car manufacturers.
We’re truly independent – giving you Australia’s best car reviews.
The estimate provided does not take into account your personal circumstances but is intended to give a general indication of the cost of insurance, in order to obtain a complete quote, please visit www.budgetdirect.com.au. Estimate includes 15%^ online discount.
^Conditions Apply
Budget Direct Insurance arranged by Auto & General Services Pty Ltd ACN 003 617 909(AGS) AFSL 241 411, for and on behalf of the insurer, Auto & General Insurance Company Limited(ABN 42 111 586 353, AFSL 285 571).Because we don’t know your financial needs, we can’t advise you if this insurance will suit you. You should consider your needs and the Product Disclosure Statement before making a decision to buy insurance. Terms and conditions apply.
Indicative quote based on assumptions including postcode , 40 year old male with no offences, licence suspensions or claims in the last 5 years, a NCD Rating 1 and no younger drivers listed. White car, driven up to 10,000kms a year, unfinanced, with no modifications, factory options and/or non-standard accessories, private use only and garaged at night.
^Online Discounts Terms & Conditions
1. Discounts apply to the premium paid for a new Budget Direct Gold Comprehensive Car Insurance, Third Party Property Only or Third Party Property, Fire & Theft Insurance policy initiated online on or after 29 March 2017. Discounts do not apply to optional Roadside Assistance.
2. Discounts do not apply to any renewal offer of insurance.
3. Discounts only apply to the insurance portion of the premium. Discounts are applied before government charges, taxes, levies and fees, including instalment processing fees (as applicable). The full extent of discounts may therefore be impacted.
4. We reserve the right to change the offer without notice.